India's major rating firms include Crisil, the Indian unit of S&P Global; ICRA, the local unit of Moody's Investors Service.
Mounting
debt failures in India have been catching rating companies off guard,
underscoring continued challenges a year after the landmark failure
of shadow bank IL&FS increased scrutiny of the industry.
Defaults
at companies including Dewan Housing Finance Corp., Cox & Kings
Ltd. and Altico Capital India Ltd. have occurred even as their
long-term ratings indicated very low to moderate risk of non-payment.
“Raters
have not been able to detect stress in time,” said Ashutosh
Khajuria, chief financial officer at Federal Bank Ltd. “Cutting
credit profiles after the defaults is no rocket science.”
There’s
a lot at stake as India tries to navigate a shadow-banking crisis and
expand its debt market. The lack of more forewarning on payment
problems has fueled questions about the quality of ratings, and could
keep some investors away from corporate bonds, hindering market
development.
India’s
major rating firms include Crisil, the Indian unit of S&P Global;
ICRA, the local unit of Moody’s
Investors Service; Fitch-owned India Ratings & Research; and
Care Ratings.
Crisil
declined to comment on industry practices, adding that it didn’t
rate most of the large credits that defaulted recently. ICRA,
Care and India Ratings & Research didn’t immediately comment.
The
securities market regulator strengthened disclosure rules earlier
this year after rating firms failed to give ample warning on IL&FS
group’s defaults from 2018, which triggered a prolonged cash
squeeze in the nation. They now have to reveal annual default rates
among the companies they evaluate.The new rules are set to improve
the quality of ratings in the industry over time, said Somasekhar
Vemuri, senior director at Crisil.